If you don’t have anything nice to say, shut your damn mouth!

Posted on Jul 09 in breastfeeding, Featured, living simply, parenting, personal stories, societyby PrintText Resizer Text Resizer

Ignorance and judgment abound in the world of a breastfeeding mom, I know first hand. These days with the popularity of social media more and more people are sharing their opinions and points of view, in this case a number of people in my network were in an uproar about comments a radio show host, Lisa Rollins of South Carolina, made regarding breastfeeding in public.



If you are curious you can read the transcripts from the show here (I don’t want to link directly to the show because it only drives their traffic and makes them money of this bullshit).

Anyway, about 5 minutes in she starts going off about this poor breastfeeding mom she saw over the weekend. Super offensive stuff. Made my blood just boil and that was last night. Today I am still fuming but calm enough to draft a non-fu-stupid-bitch letter to send her way. Here is what I wrote:

I was listening to your morning show online and was deeply shocked and offended. It wasn’t because you had a differing opinion than me, because that is your right. I was appalled that in trying to express your opinion you were blatantly shaming and embarrassing that breastfeeding mom (and other breastfeeding mom’s) on public radio.

How judgmental and ignorant of you to publicly rant about a woman nursing her baby in public. Don’t you think it is classless and in poor taste to rant about your disgust on the radio where that poor mom probably heard it all? I sure do!

Our perspectives on things are often related to the choices we’ve made. Your point of view on public breastfeeding is definitely because you choose to not breastfeed but how dare you judge others and publicly criticize them on your radio show. In doing this you’ve just shown your ignorance on the topic and your nasty, judgmental, elitist personality.

I was also thinking, if it was such a huge deal to you why didn’t you speak with the woman right then and there or why didn’t you go to restaurant management? Is it because you knew it wouldn’t be acceptable to single her out or is it because you are a coward hiding behind your microphone?

I wonder how you would feel if people publicly criticized you, whispered, stared and made you feel ashamed for bottle feeding your daughter. If you had to hear “what a selfish mom to deny her developing baby the best nourishment available” or “coward” or “how disgusting” each time you were in public tending to the needs of your baby. You might start to understand how it feels if you had.

It is super snobby of you to look down your nose at women who choose to breastfeed in public. It is not realistic to expect a woman to always be nursing in private. Babies eat and are entitled to be able to eat in the same comfort as bottle fed babies, to expect anything different is discrimination and if the tables were turned I am sure you would be just as upset as the pro-breastfeeding moms are right now.

I wonder how many times you bottle fed your daughter in public… Why didn’t you feed her in the hot car or on the toilet like you expect breastfeeding mom’s to do? Don’t you know the use of a bottle or pacifier evokes the same disgusted reaction in pro-breastfeeding folks as does the sight of an nursing baby to those squeamish anti-breastfeeding folks?

How dare you impose your view of “poor taste” on us. I am sure you’ve noticed that many, many other people feel It is in poor taste that you uttered your anti-breastfeeding comments.

The sad thing is you probably never even stopped to think about how your words would impact that nursing mother and other nursing mothers all over the world. Furthermore, how your ignorant comments have impacted the well-being and health of future babies whose mothers won’t even consider breastfeeding because of the public scrutiny and judgments of people like you.

Way to go! Hope you succeeded in achieving your desired reaction with the radio show topic. You’ve made yourself and your company look bad, you’ve made women feel ashamed for doing what their bodies were made for, you’ve pissed off a whole lot of breastfeeding advocates and you’ve taken the best nutrition available from many babies with your ignorant and hurtful comments.

I sent my email off and don’t expect a response of any kind, especially since the radio station isn’t concerned about the overwhelmingly negative response they’ve already received on their facebook page. Wait, I stand corrected. They are removing comments and photos posted by those pro-breastfeeding users… Nice.

Anyway, it just makes me sick how rude, judgmental and self centered some people are. Especially when it comes to the needs of babies and children. I know so much has to do with society’s ignorance about breastfeeding but still, it pisses me off.

[Slashdot] [Digg] [Reddit] [del.icio.us] [Facebook] [Technorati] [Google] [StumbleUpon]
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Anti-breastfeeding rants of any kind make me twitchy. Lots twitchy.

Nicely put! It sounds a lot nicer than what I would have said. I'm proud of my breastfeeding wifey!

I think your response was spot on. I just don't understand WHY people, WOMEN especially, have to be so negative about something that is natural and best for their baby?

I am so glad you sent her that email. She is just a ignorant individual and her rude ass comments are making it harder for women who are already insecure ,that are choosing to breastfeed , to continue to breastfeed .people should not look down on them. We should be supporting all mothers to try to breastfeed instead of looking down on them.

This is what I wrote:

I heard about the supper offensive and ignorant rant about breastfeeding all the way from Australia.

I hope the lady who was breastfeeding her child continues to do so and enjoys the beautiful bond between mother and baby while giving her baby the best start to life. I hope she ignores the hurtful, offensive comments made by the ignorant talkshow host and knows that she is among millions of mothers who have breastfed their babies for thousands of years.

What you choose to do is your own choice, breastfeeding or bottlefeeding and nobody should make you feel uncomfortable or belittled doing what you choose to do for your baby. NOBODY HAS THAT RIGHT.

I'm angry.

I'm going over to their facebook page for some abuse :-)

You go, girl! What an insensitive, I-D-10-T, uninformed person! So, in other words, because this DJ is so extremely upset over a natural function, she feels it is her right to dictate when a woman can feed a baby in public?!? Good thing she wasn't near me the day I went down with family to the Diamondback's ball park, with my nearly 2-month-old baby, and he suddenly decided he had to eat and wouldn't wait for me to sit down somewhere; so I put a blanket around him and breastfed him - period. Nobody said word one. I agree with her co-host; she should have just gone somewhere else to eat. I think there should be an indecency law against people who want to whine and complain about moms who choose to breastfeed - and use a roll of duct tape on the offending person as well! Good lord! What in the world is this DJ afraid of?? What an idiot! She The MOM should be more discreet??? Excuse me - the DJ said she couldn't see her breast or part of the baby's head - maybe she should move to another state where she won't be offended! Obviously this non-nursing mom has no clue you can't just "milk yourself" on demand! Now I'm offended!

OH...this lady will get hers...with all the intelligent and passionate breastfeeding mommas and their supporters, I am sure she will get more than she bargained for. I shall not say what I really wish to...

I would hate to see HER eat in public...big nasty pig.

OMG!! I would have let her have it too. I am listening to the broadcast now, but haven't heard anything yet. I think I might just like their facebook page simply to post a comment about this.

Back to Top